Insights
Where to stay

Vacation rentals in Fire Island

Search and compare Fire Island, NY holiday rentals from hundreds of travel sites on HotelsCombined and save.

...and more

Learn why travellers love HotelsCombined

Compare hotel ratings collected from thousands of user reviews.

One search gives you accurate pricing on affordable hotels.

Customie your results by hotel chain, amenities, price and more.

Search for hotels as many times as you want – for free.

Travel insights for holiday rentals in Fire Island

Use these up-to-date, data-driven insights about booking a holiday rental in Fire Island including ideal times to book, pricing trends, and more.

What is the cheapest day to stay in a vacation rental in Fire Island?

The cheapest day to stay in Fire Island is Tuesday (S$ 1,036). On the other hand, travelers can expect to pay the most on Sunday, when the average nightly price is S$ 3,891.
Find deals

Where to stay in Fire Island

Explore different neighbourhoods and areas within Fire Island to find the perfect location for your stay. Map data was last updated on 16 September 2025.
Scroll to and zoom in on the areas in Fire Island you plan on visiting to find nearby properties. You can find more information on a particular vacation rental within the map by clicking on its name.

Facts about staying in Fire Island

Find useful tips and insights about staying in Fire Island to help you make the most of your experience. FAQs were last updated on 16 September 2025.

  • How much does a holiday rental in Fire Island cost?

    On average, it costs S$ 996 per night for a Fire Island holiday rental, but S$ 961 per night or less would be considered a good deal. The cheapest holiday rental price our users have found recently in Fire Island was for S$ 204 per night. If you can, try to avoid booking your rental July (as this is the most expensive month). Booking May (the cheapest month) may end up saving you money.

Find better results for your stay in Fire Island

Consider other places to stay in Fire Island

Stay at one of these places that users have found on HotelsCombined.
Fire Island Bed & Breakfasts
Fire Island Inns
Fire Island Motels
Fire Island Resorts

Search cheap hotels with HotelsCombined. Use the hotel finder to search for the cheapest hotel deal for all major destinations around the world. HotelsCombined searches hundreds of hotel booking sites to help you find hotels and book hotels that suit you best. Since HotelsCombined searches many hotel sites at once, you can find discount hotels quickly. Discover hotel discounts now and make your hotel reservation today.