Search and compare Fire Island, NY vacation rentals from hundreds of travel sites and save.
Fire Island, NY, United States
4 May — 5 May2
Fire Island, NY, United States
Sat 4-5
Sun 5-5
...and more
Tips for booking holiday rentals in Fire Island
Gain useful insights and advice for booking the perfect stay in Fire Island. Price data is based on averages over the past 12 months and was last updated on 27 April 2024.
Average price per night / 3-star hotel. Prices are not fixed and may vary with time.
Where to stay in Fire Island
Explore different neighbourhoods and areas within Fire Island to find the perfect location for your stay. Map data was last updated on 27 April 2024.
Scroll to and zoom in on the areas in Fire Island you plan on visiting to find nearby properties. You can find more information on a particular vacation rental within the map by clicking on its name.
Facts about staying in Fire Island
Find useful tips and insights about staying in Fire Island to help you make the most of your experience. FAQs were last updated on 27 April 2024.
How much does a holiday rental in Fire Island cost?
On average, it costs S$ 1,245 per night for a Fire Island holiday rental, but S$ 1,208 per night or less would be considered a good deal. The cheapest holiday rental price our users have found recently in Fire Island was for S$ 312 per night. If you can, try to avoid booking your rental December (as this is the most expensive month). Booking April (the cheapest month) may end up saving you money.
Find better results for your stay in Fire Island
Popular holiday destinations in New York
Find holiday rentals in popular New York cities that fit your unique needs
Real ratings and reviews from millions of guests, just like yourself. Book your perfect stay with confidence!
Best Hotel Deals
HotelsCombined sources over 3 million hotels and properties and compiles them in one place so you can compare the ideal accommodation.
Free Cancellation
Plans change — we get it. And that’s why you can search and book hotels and accommodations on HotelsCombined from agencies that offer free cancellation
